12 February 2012
An Instinct for Kindness is written and performed by Chris Larner, directed by Hannah Eidenow, and produced by James Seabright. Nervously and with some trepidation, Deborah Caulfield went to see the play at Swindon Arts Centre on Thursday 9th February.
Critically acclaimed at the 2011 Edinburgh Fringe, An Instinct for Kindness is a one-man play, performed by the author, about the agony of self-determined death and the particular kind of grief that follows.
It is indeed a harrowing story that, according to the reviews is impossible to see it without feeling deeply moved. Lyn Gardner wrote in The Guardian: ‘… half the audience is in pieces long before the end.’
On a dark and empty stage, barefoot in shirtsleeves, Chris Larner and a chair enact the whole story. Between them they play all the parts, including: Chris and Allyson, old friends and ex husband and wife; George, their son; Vivienne, Allyson’s sister; the empathetic Swiss chambermaid; the Dignitas doctors.
The opening scene introduces us to Allyson. She is shouting and panicking as she struggles, with her walking frame, to sit down. We get the picture: Multiple Sclerosis is horrible.
A fall in the bath is followed by a spell in a rehab ward which, Chris recounts, steals her spirit and replaces it with fear. On her 60th birthday Allyson, now using a wheelchair full time, declares there is nothing to celebrate.
This is a story of unbearable pain and wanting out. It is less about the suffering in death, more about the intolerability of life. Allyson says, ‘I don’t want to die; I just don’t want to live. Like this.’
Chris agrees to help. George is completely against it and says so again and again. But Allyson knows her (perfectly sound) mind and she will have her way, as always. In life as in life. Adult onset disability changes the body, it doesn’t change the person.
Applying to Dignitas, Chris tells us, is a complicated process. The paperwork is mountainous and the cost is considerable, prohibitive for many one imagines.
The legal hurdles, too, are not insignificant. In the UK suicide is not against the law. However, despite attempts at legalisation, and thanks to Care not Killing's campaign, it is still a crime to assist in someone else’s suicide.
Everything has to be kept secret, lest the police turn up. This is far from easy in a household where care workers come and go all the time, letting themselves in with their own keys.
When someone blabs, Social Services call Allyson. Their concern for her mental health receives a clear rebuff: ‘I am not depressed. I do not need counselling. I want to die!’
Curiously, there is no ramp up to the front door of Dignitas.
End of story.
An Instinct For Kindness tours until 25 March 2012. For more information and dates please go to http://www.aifk.co.uk/
An Instinct for Kindness tells of a man coming to terms with helping a loved one to end her own life. Along the way he glimpses kindness in others, seeing this as glimmers of hope.
My fear is that this play provides propaganda for those campaigning to legalise assisted suicide.
I feel strongly that assisted suicide should not be decriminalised. I would go further and call for the law to be properly enforced, where currently it is not.
In my view, legalisation is a big and brutal hammer with which to crack a tiny little nut. This tiny nut is the minority of disabled or ill people who persuade someone else to kill them, perhaps on the basis that there can be no greater expression of love or, arguably, invoking their instinct for cruelty.
I’ll be honest; I am not a neutral observer in these matters.
My father had MS and died age 42. Including three ex-partners, almost all of my past and present friends and acquaintances are disabled people.
I am addicted to disability.
In sixty years as a disabled person, twenty years working in and around disabled people’s organisations, I have never met or known of any disabled person who said they wanted to die.
People have asked me for advice and help in obtaining many things, including access to information, housing, transport, education; employment, volunteering opportunities, personal assistance, and health services.
I have been asked for support to get pregnant and give birth. I have assisted disabled people to do many things, including: self advocate and self organise; exercise their political rights and citizenship responsibilities; get divorced; quit a job.
A man in Cardiff asked me to fundraise for an operation on his groin. When I said this was not the organisation’s role, he asked ‘Well what the bloody hell are you there for?’ Good question.
Very few disabled people that I am aware of are totally happy about their situation. Many are scared shitless about the rolling back of hard-won rights around independent living, choice and control. Some have taken their own lives.
No one has ever asked me to help them kill themselves. If they did, I’d say no. It’s not what I do.
Sadly, it is the case that, in the community to which I belong, depression and mental distress are commonly experienced as a consequence of the suffering inflicted upon them.
Must I repeat? It is not our impairments, or medical conditions, that make us miserable, but the segregation, isolation, exclusion, neglect and abuse to which we are subjected.
So I know all about suffering. Yet I firmly and unshakably believe that death should not be promoted as a solution to life’s problems. For me it is quite simple: Death is what happens when our life is over. Until then the law should proactively support our desire and our right to live. If it doesn’t, we’re all at risk.
The Good Funeral Guide (independent, not-for-profit consumer advice and advocacy service, here to help you arrange the funeral you want) carries a clip of the play, with self-deliverance as a keyword.